Literally- AMAZING!! For my husband‘s birthday, I made a little mini pizza tour of New York style pizza shops here in Columbus. He’s from upstate New York, and pizza just isn’t the same around here… Until we found this gem. Incredible food, amazing staff & we cannot wait to come back! You have to try the cannoli it’s Scrumptious and the pizza is just about as close to New York as you can get without being there!! Everything we tried was amazing. And to top the experience off when the staff heard of what we were doing, they even brought out something additional for us to samples just so we could get a good taste of quality pizza. That’s what local shops are all about and we just loved it.!!!!
Borgata Pizza Cafe has the best New York style pizza you can get in Columbus. The dough was perfectly baked and the sauce is reminiscent of some of the pizzas I had in NYC. The cannolis were wonderful as well. The filling was very rich and they didn't skimp on the pistachios. The service was great and our server was friendly. The prices were also fantastic for the amount of food you get. This is definitely a place you need to stop by if you want good pizza in Columbus.
We stopped for our first time here this weekend. Our server was super friendly and made some recommendations. We wound up going with a simple cheese and then a meat lovers. Both 12 inch. They were quite large and very cheesy. Not too much sauce and generous with toppings. Loved the crust and it was cooked perfectly. We will definitely be back to try out more of the menu items.
The food is good. I have had better pizza. Ordered a meatball, mushroom and onion pizza. Loaded with toppings which was great. Crust on my pie was thin and would not pass the stand test (floppy pizza). I think they would go far by making their pies a little thicker (just my opinion). Atmosphere - new and nice but is an echo chamber with all the hard surfaces. I would get some tapestries to hang (OSU carpets ) to absorbed sound) The server was a rockstar. I would go back
